Appraisal center report unfair where to sue
Publish: 2021-04-16 13:54:29
1. Isn't there an insurance company to compensate him? You don't have to file a lawsuit. If it's unreasonable, the insurance company won't let him
2. Measures for handling complaints about forensic practice activities
date of issue: April 13, 2015 16:20
(Decree No. 123 of the Ministry of justice of the people's Republic of China)
Chapter I General Provisions
Article 1 in order to standardize the handling of complaints about forensic practice activities and strengthen the supervision of forensic practice activities, These measures are formulated in accordance with the decision of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress on the administration of judicial expertise and in combination with the actual situation of judicial expertise<
Article 2 These Measures shall apply to the complainants' complaints against the judicial appraisal institutions and the practice activities of judicial appraisers examined and registered by the judicial administrative organs, as well as the complaints handling work carried out by the judicial administrative organs
Article 3 the term "complainants" as mentioned in these Measures refers to citizens, legal persons and other organizations that believe that judicial appraisal institutions and judicial appraisers have violated laws and regulations in their practice and complain to the judicial administrative organs
the complainees mentioned in these Measures refer to the judicial appraisal institutions and judicial appraisers complained
Article 4 the handling of complaints about forensic practice should follow the principles of acceptance at different levels, investigation and punishment according to law, and combination of punishment and ecation
the judicial administrative organs should protect and safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of the complainants and the complainees according to law
Article 5 the judicial administrative organ shall announce to the public the scope of accepting complaints, the communication mode of the complaint handling organ, etc., and appoint a special person to be responsible for receiving complaints
Article 6 the Ministry of justice is responsible for guiding and supervising the handling of complaints about judicial expertise practice activities nationwide<
the provincial judicial administrative organs are responsible for guiding and supervising the handling of complaints about forensic practice activities in their respective administrative regions< Article 7 the judicial administrative organ guides and supervises the Judicial Appraisal Association to implement disciplinary actions; The association assists and cooperates with the judicial administrative organs in handling complaints< Article 8 citizens, legal persons and other organizations believe that judicial expertise institutions and judicial experts have the following violations in their professional activities, Complaints may be made to the judicial administrative organ at or above the county level in the place where the judicial appraisal institution is domiciled or where the judicial appraiser's practice institution is located:
(1) engaging in judicial appraisal activities beyond the registered business scope or practice category< (2) engaging in forensic activities in violation of the rules of forensic procere< (3) causing losses to the legitimate rights and interests of the parties e to irresponsibility< (4) violation of the regulations on the administration of forensic fees< (5) the judicial appraisal institution refuses to accept the entrustment of judicial appraisal without justifiable reasons< (6) the judicial expert accepts the entrustment of judicial expertise without permission< (7) a judicial expert refuses to testify in court without justified reasons after being notified by the people's court< (8) the judicial expert intentionally makes false identification< (9) other acts in violation of the regulations on the administration of judicial expertise< Article 9 A complainant shall submit written complaint materials to the judicial administrative organ. The content of the complaint materials includes: the name of the respondent, the complaint request and the relevant facts and reasons, and provide the judicial expertise agreement, judicial expertise documents and other relevant supporting materials. The complaint materials should be true, legal and sufficient
if the complainants entrust others to make complaints, the agents shall submit the power of attorney of the complainants and their own identification
Article 10 after receiving the complaint materials, the judicial administrative organ shall immediately fill in the complaint registration form of judicial expertise practice activities. The registration form shall clearly state the name (name), gender, occupation, address and contact information of the complainants and their agents, the name (name) of the complainants, the complaint items, the complaint request, the complaint reasons, the catalogue of relevant supporting materials, and the way and time of the complaint
Article 11 after receiving the complaint materials, if the judicial administrative organ finds that the information provided by the complainants is incomplete or there are no relevant supporting materials, it shall timely inform the complainants to supplement< Article 12 a complaint shall not be accepted under any of the following circumstances:
(1) the complaint has been dealt with by the judicial administrative organ, or the case has been concluded through administrative reconsideration or administrative litigation, and there are no new facts and evidence< (2) objection to the decision of the people's court to adopt the expert opinion< (3) only dissenting from the expert opinion< (4) having objection to the rules of judicial expertise procere and the technical specifications of judicial expertise< (5) complaints are not in violation of the regulations on the administration of judicial expertise< Article 13 the judicial administrative organ shall examine the complaint materials in a timely manner, and accept the complaints that fall within its jurisdiction and meet the acceptance conditions; Complaints that do not fall within the jurisdiction of this organ or do not meet the conditions for acceptance, or that should be punished by the judicial expertise Association, shall not be accepted, but the complainants shall be informed of the ways and means to seek relief
Article 14 for complaints involving serious violations of laws and regulations, the provincial judicial administrative organ may directly accept them, or submit them to the next judicial administrative organ for acceptance< Article 15 the judicial administrative organ shall, within seven days from the date of receiving the complaint materials, make a decision on whether or not to accept the complaint, and inform the complainants or their agents in writing. If the circumstances are complicated, the time for making the acceptance decision may be appropriately extended, but the extension period shall not exceed 15 days, and the reasons for the extension shall be informed to the complainants
the time required for the complainants to supplement the complaint materials and the transfer time of the complaint cases are not included in the time limit specified in the preceding paragraph< Chapter III investigation and handling Article 16 after accepting a complaint, the judicial administrative organ shall conct an investigation. The investigation should be comprehensive, objective and fair. The investigation work shall not hinder the normal judicial expertise activities of the accused
if the judicial administrative organ considers it necessary, it may entrust the judicial administrative organ at the next level to carry out the investigation. If the respondent is a judicial expert, the judicial expert institution where he practices shall cooperate with the investigation
Article 17 when concting an investigation, the judicial administrative organ may require the respondent to explain the situation and submit relevant materials, may access the relevant business files and archival materials of the respondent, may verify the situation with relevant units and indivials, may collect evidence, and may listen to the opinions and suggestions of relevant departments
the survey should be concted by more than two staff members, and a written record should be made. The record of investigation shall be signed or sealed by the person under investigation; If the signature or seal is not available, the relevant information shall be indicated in the record< Article 18 the respondent shall truthfully state the facts and provide relevant materials, and shall not provide false or forged materials or conceal, damage or alter relevant evidence materials
Article 19 in the course of investigation, the judicial administrative organ may terminate the complaint handling work and inform the complainants of the reasons for the termination if it finds that there are circumstances specified in Article 12 of these measures
Article 20 in the course of investigation, if the judicial administrative organ finds that the respondent's illegal behavior is still in a continuous or continuous state, it shall order the respondent to stop the illegal behavior immediately< Article 21 the judicial administrative organ shall, according to the investigation results, make the following decisions:
(1) if the respondent has any illegal act that should be given administrative punishment, he shall be transferred to the judicial administrative organ with the power of punishment to give administrative punishment according to law< (2) if the defendant's violation of laws and regulations is minor and does not cause harmful consequences, and can not be given administrative punishment according to law, he shall be given criticism and ecation, admonishment, notification, order to rectify within a time limit, etc< (3) if the complaint is not verified or cannot be verified, the respondent shall not be dealt with, and the reasons for not dealing with shall be informed to the complainants in writing
those suspected of crimes shall be transferred to judicial organs for criminal responsibility< Article 22 If a judicial administrative organ accepts a complaint, it shall complete it within 60 days from the date of acceptance; If the case is complicated and cannot be completed within the prescribed time limit, the time limit may be appropriately extended with the approval of the person in charge of the organ, but the extension shall not exceed 30 days, and the reasons for the extension shall be informed to the complainants
Article 23 the judicial administrative organ shall, within seven days from the date of making the decision on handling the complaint, inform the complainants and the respondent in writing of the result of handling the complaint
Article 24 the judicial administrative organ shall timely report the result of handling the complaint to the judicial administrative organ and the Judicial Appraisal Association in the place where the respondent's domicile or practice institution is located
the judicial administrative organ shall record the result of handling the complaint into the judicial expertise practice integrity file of the respondent
Article 25 If the respondent disagrees with the decision of the judicial administrative organ to handle the complaint, he may apply for administrative reconsideration or bring an administrative lawsuit according to law
Article 26 the judicial administrative organ shall inspect and supervise the performance of the decision on punishment and treatment and the correction of violations of laws and regulations by the respondent, and order the respondent to make rectification within a time limit if problems are found< Chapter IV Supervision Article 27 the judicial administrative organ shall strengthen the guidance, supervision and inspection of the complaint handling work of the judicial administrative organ at a lower level. If any illegal or improper situation is found, it shall be ordered to make corrections in a timely manner. The judicial administrative organ at a lower level shall report the rectification in time< Article 28 If a staff member of a judicial administrative organ abuses his power, neglects his ty or commits other illegal acts in handling complaints, he shall be given administrative sanctions according to law; If a crime is constituted, criminal responsibility shall be investigated according to law
Article 29 the judicial administrative organ shall report in writing to the judicial administrative organ at the next higher level the handling of complaints about the practice of judicial expertise on an annual basis
the results of handling complaints involving major violations of laws and regulations shall be reported to the judicial administrative organ at the next higher level in a timely manner< Article 30 the judicial administrative organ shall establish, keep and use the files for handling complaints about the practice of judicial expertise< Article 31 these Measures shall come into force as of June 1, 2010.
date of issue: April 13, 2015 16:20
(Decree No. 123 of the Ministry of justice of the people's Republic of China)
Chapter I General Provisions
Article 1 in order to standardize the handling of complaints about forensic practice activities and strengthen the supervision of forensic practice activities, These measures are formulated in accordance with the decision of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress on the administration of judicial expertise and in combination with the actual situation of judicial expertise<
Article 2 These Measures shall apply to the complainants' complaints against the judicial appraisal institutions and the practice activities of judicial appraisers examined and registered by the judicial administrative organs, as well as the complaints handling work carried out by the judicial administrative organs
Article 3 the term "complainants" as mentioned in these Measures refers to citizens, legal persons and other organizations that believe that judicial appraisal institutions and judicial appraisers have violated laws and regulations in their practice and complain to the judicial administrative organs
the complainees mentioned in these Measures refer to the judicial appraisal institutions and judicial appraisers complained
Article 4 the handling of complaints about forensic practice should follow the principles of acceptance at different levels, investigation and punishment according to law, and combination of punishment and ecation
the judicial administrative organs should protect and safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of the complainants and the complainees according to law
Article 5 the judicial administrative organ shall announce to the public the scope of accepting complaints, the communication mode of the complaint handling organ, etc., and appoint a special person to be responsible for receiving complaints
Article 6 the Ministry of justice is responsible for guiding and supervising the handling of complaints about judicial expertise practice activities nationwide<
the provincial judicial administrative organs are responsible for guiding and supervising the handling of complaints about forensic practice activities in their respective administrative regions< Article 7 the judicial administrative organ guides and supervises the Judicial Appraisal Association to implement disciplinary actions; The association assists and cooperates with the judicial administrative organs in handling complaints< Article 8 citizens, legal persons and other organizations believe that judicial expertise institutions and judicial experts have the following violations in their professional activities, Complaints may be made to the judicial administrative organ at or above the county level in the place where the judicial appraisal institution is domiciled or where the judicial appraiser's practice institution is located:
(1) engaging in judicial appraisal activities beyond the registered business scope or practice category< (2) engaging in forensic activities in violation of the rules of forensic procere< (3) causing losses to the legitimate rights and interests of the parties e to irresponsibility< (4) violation of the regulations on the administration of forensic fees< (5) the judicial appraisal institution refuses to accept the entrustment of judicial appraisal without justifiable reasons< (6) the judicial expert accepts the entrustment of judicial expertise without permission< (7) a judicial expert refuses to testify in court without justified reasons after being notified by the people's court< (8) the judicial expert intentionally makes false identification< (9) other acts in violation of the regulations on the administration of judicial expertise< Article 9 A complainant shall submit written complaint materials to the judicial administrative organ. The content of the complaint materials includes: the name of the respondent, the complaint request and the relevant facts and reasons, and provide the judicial expertise agreement, judicial expertise documents and other relevant supporting materials. The complaint materials should be true, legal and sufficient
if the complainants entrust others to make complaints, the agents shall submit the power of attorney of the complainants and their own identification
Article 10 after receiving the complaint materials, the judicial administrative organ shall immediately fill in the complaint registration form of judicial expertise practice activities. The registration form shall clearly state the name (name), gender, occupation, address and contact information of the complainants and their agents, the name (name) of the complainants, the complaint items, the complaint request, the complaint reasons, the catalogue of relevant supporting materials, and the way and time of the complaint
Article 11 after receiving the complaint materials, if the judicial administrative organ finds that the information provided by the complainants is incomplete or there are no relevant supporting materials, it shall timely inform the complainants to supplement< Article 12 a complaint shall not be accepted under any of the following circumstances:
(1) the complaint has been dealt with by the judicial administrative organ, or the case has been concluded through administrative reconsideration or administrative litigation, and there are no new facts and evidence< (2) objection to the decision of the people's court to adopt the expert opinion< (3) only dissenting from the expert opinion< (4) having objection to the rules of judicial expertise procere and the technical specifications of judicial expertise< (5) complaints are not in violation of the regulations on the administration of judicial expertise< Article 13 the judicial administrative organ shall examine the complaint materials in a timely manner, and accept the complaints that fall within its jurisdiction and meet the acceptance conditions; Complaints that do not fall within the jurisdiction of this organ or do not meet the conditions for acceptance, or that should be punished by the judicial expertise Association, shall not be accepted, but the complainants shall be informed of the ways and means to seek relief
Article 14 for complaints involving serious violations of laws and regulations, the provincial judicial administrative organ may directly accept them, or submit them to the next judicial administrative organ for acceptance< Article 15 the judicial administrative organ shall, within seven days from the date of receiving the complaint materials, make a decision on whether or not to accept the complaint, and inform the complainants or their agents in writing. If the circumstances are complicated, the time for making the acceptance decision may be appropriately extended, but the extension period shall not exceed 15 days, and the reasons for the extension shall be informed to the complainants
the time required for the complainants to supplement the complaint materials and the transfer time of the complaint cases are not included in the time limit specified in the preceding paragraph< Chapter III investigation and handling Article 16 after accepting a complaint, the judicial administrative organ shall conct an investigation. The investigation should be comprehensive, objective and fair. The investigation work shall not hinder the normal judicial expertise activities of the accused
if the judicial administrative organ considers it necessary, it may entrust the judicial administrative organ at the next level to carry out the investigation. If the respondent is a judicial expert, the judicial expert institution where he practices shall cooperate with the investigation
Article 17 when concting an investigation, the judicial administrative organ may require the respondent to explain the situation and submit relevant materials, may access the relevant business files and archival materials of the respondent, may verify the situation with relevant units and indivials, may collect evidence, and may listen to the opinions and suggestions of relevant departments
the survey should be concted by more than two staff members, and a written record should be made. The record of investigation shall be signed or sealed by the person under investigation; If the signature or seal is not available, the relevant information shall be indicated in the record< Article 18 the respondent shall truthfully state the facts and provide relevant materials, and shall not provide false or forged materials or conceal, damage or alter relevant evidence materials
Article 19 in the course of investigation, the judicial administrative organ may terminate the complaint handling work and inform the complainants of the reasons for the termination if it finds that there are circumstances specified in Article 12 of these measures
Article 20 in the course of investigation, if the judicial administrative organ finds that the respondent's illegal behavior is still in a continuous or continuous state, it shall order the respondent to stop the illegal behavior immediately< Article 21 the judicial administrative organ shall, according to the investigation results, make the following decisions:
(1) if the respondent has any illegal act that should be given administrative punishment, he shall be transferred to the judicial administrative organ with the power of punishment to give administrative punishment according to law< (2) if the defendant's violation of laws and regulations is minor and does not cause harmful consequences, and can not be given administrative punishment according to law, he shall be given criticism and ecation, admonishment, notification, order to rectify within a time limit, etc< (3) if the complaint is not verified or cannot be verified, the respondent shall not be dealt with, and the reasons for not dealing with shall be informed to the complainants in writing
those suspected of crimes shall be transferred to judicial organs for criminal responsibility< Article 22 If a judicial administrative organ accepts a complaint, it shall complete it within 60 days from the date of acceptance; If the case is complicated and cannot be completed within the prescribed time limit, the time limit may be appropriately extended with the approval of the person in charge of the organ, but the extension shall not exceed 30 days, and the reasons for the extension shall be informed to the complainants
Article 23 the judicial administrative organ shall, within seven days from the date of making the decision on handling the complaint, inform the complainants and the respondent in writing of the result of handling the complaint
Article 24 the judicial administrative organ shall timely report the result of handling the complaint to the judicial administrative organ and the Judicial Appraisal Association in the place where the respondent's domicile or practice institution is located
the judicial administrative organ shall record the result of handling the complaint into the judicial expertise practice integrity file of the respondent
Article 25 If the respondent disagrees with the decision of the judicial administrative organ to handle the complaint, he may apply for administrative reconsideration or bring an administrative lawsuit according to law
Article 26 the judicial administrative organ shall inspect and supervise the performance of the decision on punishment and treatment and the correction of violations of laws and regulations by the respondent, and order the respondent to make rectification within a time limit if problems are found< Chapter IV Supervision Article 27 the judicial administrative organ shall strengthen the guidance, supervision and inspection of the complaint handling work of the judicial administrative organ at a lower level. If any illegal or improper situation is found, it shall be ordered to make corrections in a timely manner. The judicial administrative organ at a lower level shall report the rectification in time< Article 28 If a staff member of a judicial administrative organ abuses his power, neglects his ty or commits other illegal acts in handling complaints, he shall be given administrative sanctions according to law; If a crime is constituted, criminal responsibility shall be investigated according to law
Article 29 the judicial administrative organ shall report in writing to the judicial administrative organ at the next higher level the handling of complaints about the practice of judicial expertise on an annual basis
the results of handling complaints involving major violations of laws and regulations shall be reported to the judicial administrative organ at the next higher level in a timely manner< Article 30 the judicial administrative organ shall establish, keep and use the files for handling complaints about the practice of judicial expertise< Article 31 these Measures shall come into force as of June 1, 2010.
3. Hello:
your reply to the question is as follows:
you can ask your questions and apply for a new judicial expertise. It is recommended to entrust a lawyer to do it
if you have any questions, please contact me.
your reply to the question is as follows:
you can ask your questions and apply for a new judicial expertise. It is recommended to entrust a lawyer to do it
if you have any questions, please contact me.
4. How do you answer this question
5. In the process of litigation, if the forensic appraisal report is wrong, the court may apply to the people's court for a new appraisal
Article 27 of several provisions of the Supreme People's Court on evidence in civil litigation stipulates that the parties have objection to the conclusion of the appraisal made by the appraisal department entrusted by the people's court and apply for re appraisal; Providing evidence to prove the existence of any of the following circumstances; The people's court shall allow:
(1) the appraisal institution or appraiser does not have the relevant appraisal qualification< (2) the appraisal procere is seriously illegal
(3) the evidence for the appraisal conclusion is obviously insufficient< (4) other circumstances that cannot be used as evidence after cross examination.
Article 27 of several provisions of the Supreme People's Court on evidence in civil litigation stipulates that the parties have objection to the conclusion of the appraisal made by the appraisal department entrusted by the people's court and apply for re appraisal; Providing evidence to prove the existence of any of the following circumstances; The people's court shall allow:
(1) the appraisal institution or appraiser does not have the relevant appraisal qualification< (2) the appraisal procere is seriously illegal
(3) the evidence for the appraisal conclusion is obviously insufficient< (4) other circumstances that cannot be used as evidence after cross examination.
6. The appraisal report made by the appraisal unit must bear legal responsibility
Article 29 of several provisions of the Supreme People's Court on evidence in civil litigation, judges shall examine whether the appraisal certificate issued by the appraiser contains the following contents:
(1) the name of the client and the contents of the entrusted appraisal
(2) materials entrusted for appraisal< (3) the basis of identification and the scientific and technological means used< (4) the description of the identification process< (5) clear identification conclusion< (6) a description of the appraiser's qualification< (7) signature and seal of the appraiser and appraisal institution
Article 26 of the working proceres for judicial expertise, if the judicial expertise personnel of the people's court commit malpractice for personal gains and commit serious irresponsibility, resulting in wrong identification and misjudged cases, they shall be investigated for responsibility with reference to the measures for investigating the judicial responsibility of judicial personnel of the people's court for violation of law (Trial Implementation) and the measures for judicial disciplinary measures of the people's Court (Trial Implementation)
other appraisers who lead to wrong cases e to wrong conclusions shall be investigated for legal responsibility according to law; If the appraisal institution does not work seriously, practices fraud, and draws the appraisal conclusion, it has to bear the legal responsibility.
Article 29 of several provisions of the Supreme People's Court on evidence in civil litigation, judges shall examine whether the appraisal certificate issued by the appraiser contains the following contents:
(1) the name of the client and the contents of the entrusted appraisal
(2) materials entrusted for appraisal< (3) the basis of identification and the scientific and technological means used< (4) the description of the identification process< (5) clear identification conclusion< (6) a description of the appraiser's qualification< (7) signature and seal of the appraiser and appraisal institution
Article 26 of the working proceres for judicial expertise, if the judicial expertise personnel of the people's court commit malpractice for personal gains and commit serious irresponsibility, resulting in wrong identification and misjudged cases, they shall be investigated for responsibility with reference to the measures for investigating the judicial responsibility of judicial personnel of the people's court for violation of law (Trial Implementation) and the measures for judicial disciplinary measures of the people's Court (Trial Implementation)
other appraisers who lead to wrong cases e to wrong conclusions shall be investigated for legal responsibility according to law; If the appraisal institution does not work seriously, practices fraud, and draws the appraisal conclusion, it has to bear the legal responsibility.
7. Complain to the local judicial bureau
according to Article 28 of the general rules of judicial expertise procere issued by the Ministry of justice, the judicial expertise institution shall complete the expertise within 30 working days from the effective date of the power of attorney. If the appraisal matters involve complex, difficult, special technical problems or the appraisal process needs a long time, it can be postponed for 30 working days with the approval of the person in charge of the appraisal institute, but the client shall be informed
If a victim of a traffic accident entrusts a disability appraisal, and the judicial appraisal institution fails to issue an appraisal opinion beyond the legal time, it is an illegal act and can complain to the local judicial bureau, which will order it to correct and punish it< Article 28 of the general rules of judicial expertise procere of the Ministry of justice
the judicial expertise institution shall complete the expertise within 30 working days from the effective date of the power of attorney
if the appraisal matters involve complex, difficult, special technical problems or the appraisal process takes a long time, the time limit for completing the appraisal can be extended with the approval of the person in charge of the agency, and the extension time limit shall not exceed 30 working days. If the time limit for appraisal is extended, the client shall be informed in time
if there is another agreement on the time limit of expert testimony between the judicial appraisal institution and the client, the agreement shall prevail
the time required to supplement or re extract the identification materials in the identification process is not included in the identification time limit
Article 9 forensic institutions and forensic experts shall be subject to supervision according to law when concting forensic activities. Those who violate relevant laws, regulations and rules shall be given corresponding administrative punishment by judicial administrative organs according to law; For those who violate the norms of the judicial expertise instry, the judicial expertise association shall give corresponding instrial sanctions.
according to Article 28 of the general rules of judicial expertise procere issued by the Ministry of justice, the judicial expertise institution shall complete the expertise within 30 working days from the effective date of the power of attorney. If the appraisal matters involve complex, difficult, special technical problems or the appraisal process needs a long time, it can be postponed for 30 working days with the approval of the person in charge of the appraisal institute, but the client shall be informed
If a victim of a traffic accident entrusts a disability appraisal, and the judicial appraisal institution fails to issue an appraisal opinion beyond the legal time, it is an illegal act and can complain to the local judicial bureau, which will order it to correct and punish it< Article 28 of the general rules of judicial expertise procere of the Ministry of justice
the judicial expertise institution shall complete the expertise within 30 working days from the effective date of the power of attorney
if the appraisal matters involve complex, difficult, special technical problems or the appraisal process takes a long time, the time limit for completing the appraisal can be extended with the approval of the person in charge of the agency, and the extension time limit shall not exceed 30 working days. If the time limit for appraisal is extended, the client shall be informed in time
if there is another agreement on the time limit of expert testimony between the judicial appraisal institution and the client, the agreement shall prevail
the time required to supplement or re extract the identification materials in the identification process is not included in the identification time limit
Article 9 forensic institutions and forensic experts shall be subject to supervision according to law when concting forensic activities. Those who violate relevant laws, regulations and rules shall be given corresponding administrative punishment by judicial administrative organs according to law; For those who violate the norms of the judicial expertise instry, the judicial expertise association shall give corresponding instrial sanctions.
8. It's not necessary to surf the Internet,
it's not a judgment,
it may also involve personal privacy issues
it's not a judgment,
it may also involve personal privacy issues
Hot content